« What have you learned today? | Main | Educating Charlie »

January 05, 2015

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Tombarrett

I agree that it is much more important that we are failing with reflection - to identify the nuance and the trail that reveals why. What have a I changed this time? What have I done differently? What is still causing the failure? Blind resilience Vs cunning resilience is a good challenge for our learners and a nice way to put it. Perhaps there are depths of resilience beyond simple repetition, beyond just chipping away. A resilience in learners attempt to reveal and reflect on what is important next time to try.

Abiwoldhuis

A great article. Always love to be challenged in my thinking. Don't forget the place of grit within this mindset. Failing without reflection would be a waste and actually really sad. Those supporting learners need to develop resilience too - resilient to let the learning happen and not manufacture success.

Linda McIver

I agree that you have conflated resilience and persistence, and I think that everything you say applies beautifully to persistence. Blindly continuing to throw the switch on a technique that doesn't work is not something we should applaud or encourage.

But I see resilience as the ability described above by Tom, to seek to identify the causes of failure and try new ways to solve the problem, rather than collapsing in a heap sobbing "it's no good, I can't do it, I'm useless" (which I suspect we all do on occasion, but when it becomes a habit it's a problem! :). To bounce back is not necessarily to bounce blindly.

I have seen kids who take a failure as clear indication that they are not capable (fixed mindset), and kids who take failure as an indication that they are missing something - these kids then get out the magnifying glass to try to spot the missing factor. This is resilience, at least in my head (if not in the dictionary).

The comments to this entry are closed.